15 replies to this topic

[Phantom]

Murray will be sentenced in 2 days time, on November 29

how do you feel about it?

what, in your opinion, should the sentence be?

[magic]

the maximums which is 4 years and in prison. I don't know if it will but I would want to.

[soap]

It's a hard one and it wouldn't be fair to look at it like a fan.

If 4 is max and it's possible to have done it worse than Murray. Then maybe 2 years. Which probably is 0,5-1 year with good behavior. And maybe even some time at his own home.

[Phantom]

soap, on 27 November 2011 - 02:58 PM, said:

If 4 is max and it's possible to have done it worse than Murray.

is it possible to have done it worse than Murray?

I mean within the limits of a manslaughter...

[soap]

Phantom, on 27 November 2011 - 03:28 PM, said:

is it possible to have done it worse than Murray?

I mean within the limits of a manslaughter...

Yes. I believe you can do a lot worse and still not intend to kill.
Murray tried to save Michael. He was just missing some equipment.

[magic]

But he knew what can be the outcome so if he really would want to safe his life, he would make sure he was the right equipment for that. Besides, he was trying to safe his own life more than Michael's in the moment when he was starting and ordering to gather the vials rather than call 911.

And since I am a fan, I can't and don't want to look at it as not fan cause it's personal to me. My view will always be based of me being fan cause that's who I am.

[soap]

magic, on 27 November 2011 - 09:43 PM, said:

And since I am a fan, I can't and don't want to look at it as not fan cause it's personal to me. My view will always be based of me being fan cause that's who I am.

It's ok that you choose that. But your view will make your answer unusable.
Sentencing are not and shall never be looked at like that.

[magic]

soap, on 27 November 2011 - 11:40 PM, said:

It's ok that you choose that. But your view will make your answer unusable.
Sentencing are not and shall never be looked at like that.

no one is going to use my answer, it's just my answer and opinion on Zoi's question. The question was "what, in your opinion, should the sentence be?" and the key words here is "in your opinion" and "should be". So my opinion the sentence should be the maximum.

[soap]

magic, on 27 November 2011 - 11:43 PM, said:

no one is going to use my answer, it's just my answer and opinion on Zoi's question. The question was "what, in your opinion, should the sentence be?" and the key words here is "in your opinion" and "should be". So my opinion the sentence should be the maximum.

But somehow you kept to the maximum amount giving by law/court.
If it was just your opinion, then why didn't you say for life?

[Sharon007]

The Jury gave a full verdict of Guilty. I think Murray should serve 4 years. I do hope that he serves the full term. In the USA he could also be given 4 years but only do 2 and be let out for good behaviour. I think tomorrow is when we find out his fate. But I am not worried about him now. I am glad that he was found guilty. Whatever happens to him now I dont care.

[magic]

soap, on 28 November 2011 - 12:25 PM, said:

But somehow you kept to the maximum amount giving by law/court.
If it was just your opinion, then why didn't you say for life?

cause we already know maximum and it's not for life so I can';t even dream about it. But 4 years is possible.

[Phantom]

also in my opinion, he should get maximum (4 years)

I know that he won't stay inside the prison for so long...

but what matters to me most is that his medical licence is taken

[soap]

OK. I think the same as Sharon. Now he doesn't matter to me.

[Phantom]

finally he did get the maximum punishment (4 years)

and, I will agree with the Pastor, he didn't even show a little remorse...

if he had showed a little that he had regretted, and if he didn't keep accusing Michael until the very end, maybe I would be happy enough with a smaller punishment

because if he had showed that he was sad for what happened, and admitted that he made some mistakes (or several), at least he would seem more human

I mean, either way, the result of that night was a person to die, shouldn't he at least apologise to the victim's family?

even if he didn't think that it was entirely his fault, it was obvious that he was somehow involved...

[Sharon007]

i do believe the judge did give the correct sentence. I do hope that he serves it all and pays for what he did. Murray will no longer be a doctor and will probably pay for this the rest of his life. What Murray did was wrong he didnt care for his patient Michael was an experiement for him. Also the recording Murray made of Michael before he passed was going to be used to blackmail him. That is so wrong and something a doctor shouldnt do. Also he showed no remorse and the only thing we got from him was when he blew a kiss to his girlfriend .

[yagtmi07]

magic, on 27 November 2011 - 11:43 PM, said:

no one is going to use my answer, it's just my answer and opinion on Zoi's question. The question was "what, in your opinion, should the sentence be?" and the key words here is "in your opinion" and "should be". So my opinion the sentence should be the maximum.