13 replies to this topic

[Sugar_Plum]

Steven Tyler is one of the few performers whose live songs are not worse than studio version ....aerosmith has something... idk, i mean, they're in their 60's and they still got it, even steven still has his voice, it's amazing u know, after 40 years of abuse...

[magic]

I also like Aeorosmith but Metallica I like more

[soap]

They are ok, but I don't think they are the best rock band

And he do ok live.

By the way I do like him as a judge in the new American Idol.

Metallica is heavy metal and not rock.

[Sugar_Plum]

that's very personal..for which who is the best group....

uuppss...sorry not best probably cause every people is band which likes them best... this one is LEGENDARY!!!! steven tyler too!! yeah...and @ american idol he is great either...

[magic]

I wouldn't call Metallica heavy metal Maybe they were heavy metal when they appeared cause it was hard back then, but not anymore.

I've seen just one episode of American Idol with him as a judge. He didn't speak there other than yes or no.

[soap]

I don't see it as being personal.
Everybody has their own opinions.

I don't like them very much. They have maybe a few good songs. But that's it for me.

[soap]

magic, on 05 February 2011 - 10:24 PM, said:

I wouldn't call Metallica heavy metal Maybe they were heavy metal when they appeared cause it was hard back then, but not anymore.

Maybe they have changed. But still their old music is there

magic, on 05 February 2011 - 10:24 PM, said:

I've seen just one episode of American Idol with him as a judge. He didn't speak there other than yes or no.

Ok. Usually he speaks a lot and sings and other things. He is kind of funny in there.

[magic]

Quote

Maybe they have changed. But still their old music is there

they also have change, everybody changes. But also other music changes and styles changes as well. I mean the way how they are based in styles. New harder bands come so they are more heavy than Metallica so that's why I don't count them as heavy metal. There are groups that are heavier than them.

Quote

Ok. Usually he speaks a lot and sings and other things. He is kind of funny in there.

Ok, I wouldn't know that. We don't have new season and I don't follow them on YouTube

[Sugar_Plum]

Ok, I wouldn't know that. We don't have new season and I don't follow them on YouTube



Yes,i know on TV not NEW season! but here it is ... soo enjoyed!! 10, season!! now is up to 6.auditions!!

y welcome - http://eztv.it/shows/9/american-idol/

[soap]

magic, on 05 February 2011 - 11:01 PM, said:

they also have change, everybody changes. But also other music changes and styles changes as well. I mean the way how they are based in styles. New harder bands come so they are more heavy than Metallica so that's why I don't count them as heavy metal. There are groups that are heavier than them.

Then lets call it hard rock
But just because some people choose to make even harder rock doesn't mean everyone less hard will change category

[magic]

yes it means exactly that. The styles changes all the time.

[soap]

magic, on 06 February 2011 - 12:52 PM, said:

yes it means exactly that. The styles changes all the time.

No. It doesn't. Instead they add an even harder category. They don't change the existent categories.

[Phantom]

I also like Metallica a lot

many people think that Metallica belong in Heavy Metal category, and also many other people think that Metallica belong in Hard Rock category

I like their music either way

I like Aerosmith too

I like first Come Together with Aerosmith, second Come Together with Michael Jackson, and third Come Together with Beatles

I don't know why, maybe I like more the hard side of this song, that is performed by Aerosmoth

[Sharon007]

I like Dont Want To Miss A Thing by Aerosmith and Whiskey in the Jar by Metallica although I watched the original of this being performed recently and it was amazing the original member of the bad is in his 60s now but boy he still has it.